As we enjoy the unofficial end of summer on this Labor Day, it’s good to remember those who do their difficult jobs well with little fanfare and in some cases, with some risk involved. One recent example is the case of Alex Wubbles, a Utah nurse who was arrested in July for simply following the basics of patient care when she stopped a police officer from taking blood from an unconscious patient without any warrant or consent.
If you have seen the troubling body-cam video of the incident, you can see the nurse calmly explain to the officer why she could not allow him to draw blood from the patient. During the confrontation, she spoke to her supervisor on the phone, who was able to confirm the correctness of her actions. Even this did not stop the officer from dramatically taking her into custody.
Clearly, this was an extraordinary occasion. However, we mustn’t miss an important point: Alex Wubbles put her patient’s rights first. By demonstrating patient-centered care, she valued the patient as a human being. This is medical care (and, by extension, bioethics) at its best. Even in the best of times, being a patient in the hospital can be a wearying and disorienting experience—all of the professionals coming in and out of the room, the strange sounding terminology, accompanied by the uneasy feeling that no one is listening to you. In the midst of it all, it is important to remember that the rights of the most vulnerable are as important as those of the most powerful.