Scene: the boardroom of a large NHS Trust, somewhere in England.
“And so that brings us neatly to the last item on the agenda: passport checks for pregnant women who want a checkup. The thing is, you see, that it turns out that we’ve been providing obstetric care to some women who aren’t actually UK citizens. And, clearly, that has to stop.”
“Well, maybe not stop. But you know what I mean. We can’t go providing treatment to anyone who comes knocking at the door! Why, we’d have a queue from here to Timbuktu, not to mention the cost!”
“Oh, quite. No, I quite agree that we can’t be the world’s supplier of healthcare.”
“No. So that’s settled, then. No more obstetric services to women who can’t demonstrate their eligibility.”
“You don’t look convinced. What’s the problem? These women aren’t eligible.”
“Well, no. But… well, look. Remember when Dr Smith retired, and when Dr Jones got that transfer to work in the Inner Hebrides?”
“All too well. Two great losses to the Trust. What’s your point?”
“Well, I seem to remember that we pooled together to buy them nice leaving presents.”
“We did. It was the least we could do.”
“I agree. But, you see, the thing is, they weren’t actually entitled to them. If you see what I mean.”
“I’m not sure I follow.”
“No. Well, you see, the thing is, we bought them those presents, and gave them to them, because it’s the decent thing to do. There’s no rule that says that we have to buy them. They wouldn’t have been wronged if we hadn’t.”
“Yeeeeeeessssss… I mean, no. But yes.”
“But we gave them the presents anyway. Because the rules set out what’s minimially decent. Not an upper limit.”
“Well, you see, I was just wondering: might the same apply in other contexts? Allowing for the obvious differences, of course.”
“You’re losing me again.”
“I thought I might be. Well, you see, it’s like this. We’ve been providing treatment to pregnant women without paying attention to whether they’re entitled by the strict letter of the law. And that law specifies who is entitled to treatment.
The views, opinions and positions expressed by these authors and blogs are theirs and do not necessarily represent that of the Bioethics Research Library and Kennedy Institute of Ethics or Georgetown University.