Bioethics Blogs

Medicare’s Proposed Rule Is Just the First Step

As Jane Jankowski, DPS, LMSW discussed in her last AMBI blog posted on June 16, 2015, the proposed rule to reimburse providers for conversations with patients about advance care planning takes a positive step toward educating patients on end-of-life medical considerations by incentivizing doctors to take the time to address these issues in the clinical setting.  Assuming that such reimbursements depend only on raising the topic of advance care planning with patients and not on the content of a patient’s choices (such as whether or not a patient chooses to forego treatment), encouraging health care providers to discuss health care decision making in advance with patients can go a long way to support patient autonomy and provide helpful guidance to surrogate decision-makers when a patient lacks capacity.  Doctors often cite lack of time as a reason why they do not address advance directives in the clinical setting, but this rule would compensate doctors for their time, allowing them more flexibility in allocating time to address these issues.  However, the proposed rule does nothing to ensure that the providers having these conversations are equipped with the proper tools and training to do so.

Advance directives, although they address the provision of medical treatments, are legal documents that can be complex and far-reaching, and therefore are not necessarily self-explanatory to patients or providers.  Many states offer a statutory form advance directive as an example, but all too often these forms may be merely printed by a provider and given to patients to sign without sufficient explanation.  These forms vary in their scope, but some sample living wills, such as forms from West Virginia and South Carolina, are little more than a declaration that no life-sustaining treatments should be provided.

The views, opinions and positions expressed by these authors and blogs are theirs and do not necessarily represent that of the Bioethics Research Library and Kennedy Institute of Ethics or Georgetown University.