Bioethics Blogs

Incurious about Ethics?

An Institute of Medicine committee is in the midst of a 19-month study, undertaken at the FDA’s request, of the “ethical and social policy considerations” of germline-modifying techniques that cobble together gametes or embryos produced with eggs from two women. The committee held its first public meeting on March 31 and April 1, in the wake of statements of concern about human germline gene editing by several groups of prominent scientists.

Presumably because of the Center for Genetics and Society’s longstanding interest in the techniques and their serious implications, I was invited to speak on a panel about human germline modification. The materials I received in preparation for the meeting included questions about the social and ethical implications of modifying genes that are inherited by future generations, and about the historical context of the prohibitions against human germline modification that have been put in place by several international human rights treaties and dozens of countries (though not the US).

Another question was whether it would be “advisable” to draw policy lines between therapeutic and enhancement applications of genetic modification techniques, the implication being that this might be preferable to the current widespread agreement  that encourages gene transfer to treat sick people, but puts off limits changes that would be passed on to children and subsequent generations. Several invited speakers addressed these questions from a cautionary perspective; see, for examples, here and here.

Unfortunately, most of the IOM committee members seemed remarkably incurious about these points. Few follow-up questions were asked about the societal implications of human germline modification, or about the social values and concerns that have prompted more than 40 countries to adopt laws against it.

The views, opinions and positions expressed by these authors and blogs are theirs and do not necessarily represent that of the Bioethics Research Library and Kennedy Institute of Ethics or Georgetown University.